Good news and bad news on the Elgato Turbo H.264

I’ve spent a little while playing with my new Elgato Turbo H.264 hardware video encoder. There’s good news and bad news, so far.

The good news is that it does, in fact, add a profile to iMovie, so you can export/encode video directly from there without an intermediate step of exporting in raw DV format to then encode in the little Turbo H.264 app. That’s nice, and I was worried it would be a problem. I presume this is also the case with Final Cut Express and Pro, which are mentioned in the same light as iMovie in the documentation.

More good news: the encoding is fast. Noticeably faster than just using the CPUs in my 2.33GHz Core 2 Duo Mac Book Pro. 4x faster, like they claim? Unknown, but it feels possible. I’ll try to get some benchmarks and some numbers soon, to quantify this.

The bad news: the video file encoded with the Turbo H.264 is very slightly larger (filesize), and very slightly lower quality visually (seems jaggy/aliased – a problem with interlacing?) compared to the one I exported manually using similar settings in iMovie (Quicktime, H.264, same res, etc.). 🙁

That’s not to say at all that the quality is bad – it’s not. It’s really quite good, and the differences are only noticeable upon close side-by-side inspection. The source footage I tested on was shot in HDV 60i (60 frames per second, interlaced). I’ll try some progressive footage, and see if that makes a difference. I’m not targeting anything higher than 30fps anyway, so it’s not a big deal to switch to 30p from 60i on my camera.

More to come as it’s available…


One thought on “Good news and bad news on the Elgato Turbo H.264

Comments are closed.