Rock Band 3 Review

Update: I’m really taking to the keyboard. For some reason, it’s just easier for me to play than the guitar or drums. Might have something to do with the fact that my fingers have spent the better part of every day on a (computer) keyboard for the last 28 years, since I was 5. πŸ™‚ I’ve never really developed the muscle coordination/memory for guitar or drums (not to mention having to use the bass pedal!).

However, I’m finding that I while I’m still at the medium/hard comfort level on guitar, I can dive right in to Expert on keys and do OK. Haven’t failed a song yet. I’ve even taken to playing Expert guitar parts (which I’ve never been up to before) with the keyboard during the road challenges/while I’m grinding to earn fans and unlock stuff. It just flows, and it feels pretty cool.

I picked up Rock Band 3 for the PS3 on launch day (10/26/10), along with the new wireless keyboard instrument. I’m not a hardcore player, but we love to play as a family and with friends, and have amassed the whole collection of instruments (two guitars, drums, mic, etc.) and a whole bunch of songs. The track list, along with the new keyboard, made Rock Band 3 a must buy for me. Here are my initial thoughts after a couple days of play.

Rock Band 3 Wireless Keyboard PS3

The keyboard is great – feels good, easy to pick up and play. Of course, it’s a whole new set of finger memories to learn, and since I mostly play guitar, that trips me up sometimes. But I’ve only been playing a couple of hours. Mostly experimenting, customizing characters and our band (“The Rockin’ Out Band-crofts”), etc. Most (but not all) of the songs in RB3 have a keyboard part, but none of the songs from earlier iterations will. Fortunately, you can choose to play the Guitar or Bass part with the keyboard, which on most songs, is just fine. And on songs like Freezepop’s “Less Talk More Rokk”, where the original part was a “keytar” anyway, it’s downright perfect.

Besides the 80+ songs on the disc, RB3 will automatically pick up anll the songs you have on your hard drive. In my case, all the songs from Rock Band, Lego Rock Band, and a all my DLC. I also did the Rock Band 2 “export” – it’s actually a 2GB download, using the unique code on the back of the RB2 manual – the disc never has to be inserted. The export costs $9.99, and not all songs come over (70 of the 80+ in RB2).

The graphics and band activity in the background are awesome. Your band is always hanging out, doing things appropriate to where you’re at in thr game (playing in basement and bars to begin with, etc.). The graphics are crisp and gorgeous. Text looks very nice, and while I’m not enough of a typenerd to know what font they use, I do appreciate that it looks great. Sound is excellent, too, though I had to manually switch to Dolby Digital output. You’ll have to recalibrate your setup for lag, which is a snap of you have one of the Rock Band 2 guitars with a calibration sensor on the front.

The song list, where you’ll probably spend most of your time besides playing songs, has a ton of controls, filters, and ways to look at your library, which is a very good thing, because if you’re anything like me, you have a ton of songs to manage. I’m at 320 or so, from RB1, RB2, RB3, and DLC. You can filter by source, parts, ratings (including new “Family Friendly” and “Supervision Recommended” ratings), and a bunch more criteria.

I’m not very far in the “career” mode, but it’s mostly focused around number of fans, completion of Road Challenges, and other Goals. You ant progress without dabbling in all the various goals – for example, I’ve done the first couple sets of road challenges, but even though I’ve got gold medals in all of them, I can’t unlock the next set until I “level up” my band by gaining more fans, by completing other goals. It feels like a nice balance, and if you don’t want to worry about career progression and unlocking songs, you don’t have to. All 80+ songs are playable from the start.

Speaking of goals, there’s an astounding number of them to complete, ranging from the traditional (“get 5 stars on these songs”) to the humorous to the insane (Endless Setlists, and the “Obsessive Compulsive” – play every note in every song perfectly). You will never complete all of them. I wonder if anyone at Harmonix has even done that.

Stuff I haven’t tried yet: harmony vocals, drums, online play, deep logo/outfit/tattoo customization.

Overall, I love the game. It’s the best rhythm or music game out there. Leave a comment or hit me up on email or Twitter if you have any questions about something I missed.


How I Use Twitter, October 2010

In response to an email thread/questionnaire about how various people use Twitter, I sent the following as my reply to the questions. I thought it might be interesting to share here.

I’ve been on Twitter since July 2006, and have been responsible for pushing it into many of our community efforts at work. Here’s how I use it, personally.

Listening & Posting

I keep Tweetie for Mac running on the side of my screen at all times when I’m at my computer. My timeline flows by – I don’t worry too much about reading every post. @Mentions and DMs are highlighted and usually catch my attention, and I have other ways to get notified of those types of communications. I get email for DMs, and I’ve created a search for my Twitter handle, name, and common misspellings at, and have subscribed to the RSS feed for that search, so I never miss a mention. I have in the past also done this for specific topics I want to follow/be able to respond to quickly, and I think it’s a great “best method” for listening and monitoring. I also use the official Twitter app on my iPhone and iPad a lot – my saved searches sync there, and it’s a very nice way to make sure I’m always plugged in to the stream and able to post or respond quickly, and not be tied to my computer. Twitter is just as usable and useful for me on my mobile devices as it is on my computer.

Reporting and Analytics

Honestly, I don’t worry too much about metrics and analytics. Follower and post count are just interesting numbers, not the be all end all of my Twitter usage. It’s all about the conversations and the human connections to me.


Hashtags usually get picked by the users, and forcing/creating too many specific hashtags is usually counterproductive. Go with the flow. Try to use desired keywords in your actual tweets, rather than relying too much on hashtags. They’re just a way to get a keyword into a tweet when it wouldn’t otherwise be there. Write creatively.


Learn the advanced search syntax on Learn how to exclude terms and people to better hone and filter your search results. Iterate until your search is good enough. Don’t include the # sign in your searches – just search for the word. That will catch what you’re looking for regardless of whether or not the person remembered to type the #. Save searches, and learn to use the RSS feeds for search results, to pipe them into other channels (your reader, email alerts, etc.)

Managing Followers & Bots

Don’t obsess about how many followers you have, and don’t tweet asking for more. You’ll sound like a dork. πŸ™‚ Tweet as if you had the audience you dream of, regardless of how many people follow you. Tweet well, and they will come. Don’t follow people back just because they follow you. I don’t even bother to investigate every new follower I get. Many of them are spammers, and unless I already know them somehow, I won’t follow them back anyway, so it’s a waste of time for me. I do report people who spam me with @replies as spam, and block them, but I ignore the rest. It’s not worth my time. Use Twitter Lists to organize the people you follow. Whenever I follow someone, I add them to one of my lists (work, developers, news, companies, bots, friends, etc.), and I’ve gone through all the people I follow to make sure they’re on at least one list. This gives me a way to categorize the people I follow, and filter on those categories.

Measuring Influence and Reach

To a one, I’ve found these types of tools fun to play with, but ultimately useless. They don’t really provide any significant meaning on the stuff I care about on Twitter, which is the relationships and humans I’m connecting with. Every score-based tool on Twitter does nothing but assign an arbitrary and meaningless number to you. Fun to compare with your friends, but ultimately of not much significance.

This is Just Me

What you do think? I know everyone uses Twitter for different ends and by different means. There is no right or wrong, and I’m won’t tell anyone how they should or shouldn’t use it (unless they ask me :-). Have you given any though to how and why you use tools like Twitter, Facebook, etc.?


Instagram – a Fun New Social iPhone Photo App

You’ve probably already seen these if you follow me on Twitter, Facebook, or Flickr, but here are some random photos I’ve taken over the last couple of days with [Instagram]( – a fun new iPhone app that focuses on taking quick photos, applying some filters, and sharing them with your friends.

Got an Apple Magic Trackpad. Love it so far.

When the otaku geek “influencers” I follow got all excited about Instagram, and I read what it was, I couldn’t quite grasp why they cared. Yet another app where I have to find and follow my friends? Why not just use the existing networks? And I already have [Hipstamatic]( and a ton of similar photography apps on my iPhone for when I want to make hipster pictures.

Why, yes. I *am* wearing a Hello Kitty bandage.

But with Instagram, the whole is more than the sum of its parts. It does have great integration with Flickr, Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and even Foursquare. It is super quick to take a picture, apply a filter, and share it. And there are lots of really nice design touches (especially in the News tab) that make it a joy to use. And it’s free.


That’s not to say that it’s perfect. I quickly discovered that the images it uploads (and saves to your local Camera Roll) are only 612×612 pixels. That’s tiny.

Instagram pics are only 612x612 pixels. WTF?

After I [complained about this on Twitter](, the Instagram folks invited me to [submit a full resolution picture option as an improvement on their GetSatisfaction page](, where lots of other people chimed in, and the developers agreed it would be a great feature. Hopefully it will come soon.

Sync in Progress. Story of my Life

So, if you have an iPhone, and like pictures, grab Instagram, and follow me (I’m jabancroft there, same as everywhere else), and get ready for lots of hipster-ized random photos that make no sense, but look real nice. πŸ™‚


iPhone HDR Comparison: iOS 4.1, Pro HDR, and True HDR

Now that iOS 4.1 is out for my iPhone 4, I loaded it up to try the feature I was most looking forward to: [HDR photos]( HDR stands for [High Dynamic Range](, and is a way to get a photo where neither the shadowy areas or the bright areas are overexposed. It can also be used or “abused” to commit crimes against good taste. πŸ™‚ I’ve been using two iPhone HDR apps for a while, [Pro HDR]( and [TrueHDR](, and now that Apple’s thrown its hat in the ring, it’s time for a comparison.

Here are the examples, and below them, my thoughts. The following photo was taken in my driveway last night (sunsets are generally good fodder for HDR photos). The four shots are, in order:

1. The original “non HDR” photo that iOS 4.1 optionally saves when you take an HDR shot.
2. The Apple iOS 4.1 HDR photo
3. The Pro HDR photo, taken in “Auto HDR” mode
4. The TrueHDR photo, taken using “Take Pictures” mode.

All photos are unretouched, uploaded at full resolution (available on my Flickr – click to embiggen) directly from my iPhone 4.

###Original iPhone 4 Non-HDR Photo

iPhone iOS 4.1 HDR Sunset Comparison - Original Apple Image

* __The Good__: Fast, easy, and simple. Colors captured pretty well.
* __The Bad__: Shadows and dark areas underexposed. Could have touched the dark areas to get them exposed correctly, but then the sky would be overexposed and blown out. Hence the need for HDR.
* __The Verdict__: The iPhone 4 still has an amazing camera with great saturation and color. Unless you really need HDR to make a photo better, this is all you need.

###Apple iOS 4.1 HDR Photo

iPhone iOS 4.1 HDR Sunset Comparison - Apple HDR

* __The Good__: Fast and subtle. Takes three exposures (instead of two, like Pro HDR and TrueHDR), and takes them near instantaneously (within two seconds or so). It’s still possible to get motion blur/ghosting, but it’s an order of magnitude faster than the other apps. Seems to go for realism rather than the over the top “ZOMG HDR!!1!” look. Free (if you have a device that can run iOS 4.1).
* __The Bad__: Subtle. May not give as much of that “HDR” effect you’re looking for. Colors aren’t as bright, and the image can appear a little washed out. Dark areas are still really dark (compare the grass and balloons on the left side).
* __The Verdict__: An great capability added to an already amazing camera. Will make a lot of photos better for almost no effort at all.

###Pro HDR Photo, “Auto HDR” Mode

iPhone iOS 4.1 HDR Sunset Comparison - Pro HDR, Auto Mode

* __The Good__: Auto Mode evaluates the scene, decides which bright and dark spots to expose for, then takes the two photos. Manual mode (where you pick the bright and dark spots) still available. Nice slides to adjust contrast, saturation, etc. available after the merge is complete. Does a better job handling the extremes of bright and dark than the iOS 4.1 HDR mode. Colors are bright and not too “unreal”. Only $1.99.
* __The Bad__: Even Auto mode isn’t fast enough for moving subjects. A “halo” is sometimes visible where two areas blend together (see where the trees meet the sky on the right). Sometimes the colors just _go wrong_. Merging the photos takes a few seconds (longer than iOS 4.1, but not as long as TrueHDR).
* __The Verdict__: If you’re a photography nerd like me, iOS 4.1’s HDR mode probably won’t be enough to scratch your itch. Pro HDR is a great tool for the virtual camera bag, and I recommend it without hesitation. If iOS 4.1 had never added HDR, I’d still recommend Pro HDR for taking cool HDR shots on your iPhone.

###TrueHDR Photo, “Take Pictures” Mode

iPhone iOS 4.1 HDR Sunset Comparison - True HDR, "Take Picture"

* __The Good__: Often more subtle and realistic than Pro HDR (see the balloons and grass on the left side). Doesn’t exhibit the “halo” effect as much. Does what it says on the tin. A little birdie tells me that an “auto” mode might be coming in a future update. Only $1.99.
* __The Bad__: Slowest of the three to process/merge the two photos. No adjustment sliders for contrast, saturation, etc. Colors don’t “pop” as much as Pro HDR. Sometimes the colors just _go wrong_.
* __The Verdict__: Still a great HDR app, and future improvements could move it right into parity with Pro HDR.

What I’ve written is based on these four photos, plus the experience I’ve had using both Pro HDR and True HDR for a couple of months in various situations. The differences between those two apps are small, and sometimes performs better in one situation than another, with the opposite occurring under different conditions.

In the end, if you’re an iPhone photography geek like me, you’ll want to use the built in iOS 4.1 HDR function _and_ one of the third party apps. Which one to choose is a tough call, though. If it came down to it, I’d say get Pro HDR. But software updates can change the landscape quickly, and TrueHDR is a great app, too. You won’t go wrong with either of them.


Gone Markdown Crazy

I’ve gone a bit [Markdown]( crazy today. It’s an easy way to write for the web. As someone who writes for the web a lot, it’s the most useful thing I’ve learned in ages. What took me so long?

First, I grabbed the [MarkdownMail iPhone app](, started testing it with [my Posterous](, then enabled it here on with the [WordPress plugin]( Now I’m looking for ways to use it other places – on my Mac, on my iOS devices, etc. Share any cool tricks or tools you know, please.

You probably already write at least partly in Markdown, and just don’t know it. I did.

_Update:_ I’ve switched to [Steven Frank’s branch of Notational Velocity that supports the Markdown preview pane]( I also discovered that [Tumblr]( and [MarsEdit]( support Markdown natively. I added Markdown and [SmartyPants]( as Unix Filter to [TextWrangler]( using [these instructions]( I also [added Markdown and SmartyPants as Mac OS X system Services using Automator](, so I can use them anywhere on my Mac (in TextEdit, etc.). I’m also going to install [the Markdown Syntax MediaWiki extension]( on Intelpedia, our big internal wiki at work.

See? Markdown crazy.


Fire Drill During the Apple Event Broadcast – The Solution!

As usual, my Apple nerd friends and I gathered around one of the big TVs in the “living room” area at work, so we could watch the Apple event and announcements live. Usually, it’s me flipping through all the liveblogs, seeing what tidbits we can glean as they dribble out. This time, since there was a live video stream for the first time since 2002, we were sitting pretty – we were watching and listening to Steve Jobs live on the TV. It was great.

Until, five minutes into the thing, the building sirens go off, and security comes over the PA and announces that the building is being evacuated. It was just a scheduled drill, but it was SO HARD to drag myself away from the new and exciting announcements we were just starting to hear!

As we filed out of the building, I brought up the stream on my iPhone (which worked beautifully – as a video streaming guy, I appreciate how difficult it is to get this right on such a large scale). We marched to the evacuation area in the parking lot, and by luck, my car was parked nearby. So I had an idea.

We all piled into my car (which also got us out of the rain), stuck my iPhone and the Apple stream into my car dock, and we continued to watch and listen to the event in my car during the fire drill evacuation. It was a nerd drive-in movie! πŸ™‚ Never underestimate the ingenuity of an unabashed fanboy.

Fire drill during an Apple event? Stream it on the car stereo in the parking lot! Nerd Drive-in!


Scenes from Gnomedex 10

Posting some of the photos I took at Gnomedex 10 in Seattle a couple of weeks ago. Gnomedex is my favorite conference, and I look forward to it every August as a “family reunion” of my geek people. This year was bittersweet – it was likely the last Gnomedex ever. I took lots of notes, and intend to write up a few more meaty posts on some of the thoughts I had. But for now, I’m posting these, mainly to push down my lame “Site was hacked” post, which has been sitting here for too long. πŸ™‚

All photos were taken with my iPhone 4 – I decided not to lug a “big boy” DSLR with me, and I have to say, the photo quality of the iPhone 4, coupled with the amazing apps I can use to manipulate the photos “in camera” (like Pro HDR, Autostitch, etc.) blew me away. This is now my “pocket carry” camera, and unless I really need a DSLR, probably the only one I’ll carry from now on.


Made this combination panorama and HDR shot on my iPhone 4 with Pro HDR and Autostitch, two of my favorite photo apps. Taken from the front steps of the Bell Harbor Conference Center in Seattle, home to Gnomedex for the last five years.


Chris Pirillo


The End of Gnomedex


Seattle Waterfront Panorama. Using Autostitch, of course.


Seattle Waterfront, Unretouched from iPhone 4. Love the colors on this one.


Site Was Hacked – Let Me Know If You Get Redirected

I was notified this morning by a friendly reader that my site was redirecting people to a malware site. Sure enough, upon investigation, it seems I was hit by this exploit, as written up at mediatemple.

I’m pretty sure I’ve cleaned it all up now – I can’t find any traces of infection. But I’d appreciate it if you could let me know if you see any strange behavior on the site, get redirected somewhere unexpected, etc.

I apologize for the inconvenience.

I hate spammers. πŸ™


Josh’s Lifelog for 2010-07-10